How Short Is Too Short for Men’s Pants?

I’ve been not too long ago experimenting with shorter pants, one thing I can put on with a blazer, or just a T-shirt or a sweater. I’ve been hemming a few of them, however what’s too brief? I need to steer clear of Capri pants/clown pants territory. How are you aware when you’re doing it proper? — Pavel, Athens

The male ankle! Or mankle. (I like phrase hybrids.) Of all of the physique components to be a supply of controversy, this is among the oddest. But the query of whether or not to point out or to not present the masculine talus (the official title of that nobby bone between the tibia, fibula and heel) has been a subject of debate for years. In 2005, Thom Browne, the designer who has nearly single-handedly been attempting to boost males’s hemlines, instructed The New York Times that the ankle was “the brand new male cleavage.”

Although he now largely wears shorts, Mr. Browne mentioned, once I requested him not too long ago: “Once I did put on trousers, I wore them simply above my ankle bone, and I liked them at that size. It irritated individuals, and I liked that.”

And, certainly, when a man struts round displaying off that strip of pores and skin, individuals react in the identical manner. They stare. They scratch their heads. They write articles about it — like this one. Lately The Australian Financial Review requested, “Is It Ever OK for Males to Flash Their Ankles within the Workplace?” (That isn’t a joke.)

As soon as a topic of derision popularly mocked as “flood pants,” shorter male pants grew to become a factor once more when Mr. Browne launched them again in 2001, partly as a response to the large, billowing fits of the Nineties (see Michael Jordan). Mr. Browne shrank the silhouette, narrowing the pants and slimming and shortening the jacket, making it look like the hipster model of the Nineteen Fifties firm man crossed with Buster Brown.

At first, it was one thing stunning (partly, as a result of, together with ankle-baring, Mr. Browne favors precise shorts), however in 2018 Mr. Browne sold his company to Zegna in a deal that valued it at $500 million, thus suggesting that rethinking male pants may very well be the best way ahead. Since then, it has been adopted by assorted celebrities, in addition to by Rishi Sunak, the British prime minister.

In accordance with Man Trebay, the lads’s style critic for The Occasions: “The trouser itself is the inspiration of the silhouette, and it’s the one factor males get mistaken so much. For instance, Kevin McCarthy’s too-tight dad pants, made worse by the uncovered assertion socks.”

He continued: “The easiest way to guage matches of any type is in a three-way mirror and with a trusted and ruthlessly sincere buddy close by. For a common rule of thumb, although, I consulted with Nick Wooster (@nickwooster), a method influencer with a million followers. He mentioned: ‘Typically talking, pants ought to by no means go above the ankle bone. Something above that tends to make legs seem shorter.’”

Additionally necessary, in keeping with Mr. Trebay, is “bearing in mind the width of the leg: the broader the leg, the longer it must be.” Conversely, the shorter the leg, the narrower.

Mr. Browne, nonetheless, merely suggested, “Put on garments in the best way that really feel true to you: true to your style, true to your model, true to what you need individuals to see about you.” Even when it’s your mankles!

Nonetheless, know this: After sitting via the latest males’s put on exhibits in Florence, Milan and Paris, Mr. Trebay mentioned that “in all three cities, trousers and jacket skirts have been longer than they’ve been in years.” So does the style wheel flip.

Your Fashion Questions, Answered

Each week on Open Thread, Vanessa will reply a reader’s fashion-related query, which you’ll ship to her anytime by way of email or Twitter. Questions are edited and condensed.