The Many Faces of Clean Beauty

Kjaer Weis, a make-up model made in Italy from natural olive oil, lavender and beeswax, is usually described as one of many OGs of unpolluted magnificence. However that doesn’t sit effectively with its founder.

“‘Clear magnificence’ didn’t exist once I launched in 2010 and it’s by no means been the type of exact terminology that I’ve needed to make use of,” stated Kirsten Kjaer Weis, a New York-based make-up artist.

She says she finds the absence of a regulatory framework that governs or expressly defines “clear” problematic. For her refillable lipsticks and cream foundations she prefers the time period “natural magnificence,” pointing to her label’s certification by CCPB, a non-public firm whose certifications are broadly used within the business, which verifies that her plant-based uncooked supplies are grown with out pesticides in accordance with the European Union’s rules.

Kjaer Weis’ strategy is changing into extra widespread as clear magnificence has moved from the fringes to the mainstream. Sephora, Ulta Magnificence, Credo and others promote hundreds of merchandise from dozens of manufacturers, every claiming to keep away from lengthy lists of no-go components. Like every development, clear magnificence has its dissenters, who’ve taken to TikTok to query whether or not clear merchandise are safer, or simply one other instance of greenwashing. Regulators have picked up the query too, notably within the EU, the place false environmental and well being claims include more and more stringent penalties.

The business has settled into a number of camps, which have come to an uneasy truce. There are manufacturers like Kjaer Weis, which principally observe clear magnificence greatest practices however keep away from the label; true anti-clean manufacturers that proudly use chemical compounds and different components on the “free from” lists; and clear magnificence’s defenders, who’re doubling down on the idea.

A Saturated Market

The latter group remains to be by far the most important.

Sephora locations a Clear at Sephora seal on 72 make-up SKUs from 35 manufacturers “formulated with out parabens, sulfates SLS and SLES, phthalates, mineral oils, formaldehyde, and extra.” It lately satisfied a choose to throw out a class-action lawsuit over whether or not it mislead prospects to imagine that these merchandise are pure and never dangerous.

A search on Ulta Magnificence for make-up that includes “clear components” returns 1,251 merchandise from 104 manufacturers that exclude 39 ingredient courses on its “Made With out Listing.” These merchandise comprise multiple fifth of Ulta Magnificence’s whole color cosmetics SKUs.

Maybe no retailer has embraced clear greater than Credo, the clear magnificence retailer that launched a decade in the past in New York and now has 15 shops throughout the US and by far essentially the most complete Soiled Listing banning or proscribing 2,700 components. It shares 377 merchandise from 47 manufacturers that meet the factors.

“In some ways, the enlargement of the time period has really helped Credo stand out extra,” stated Boma Brown-West, Credo’s vice chairman of sustainability. “When ‘clear’ is simply getting used as a buzzword, it doesn’t actually take that lengthy for a client to look beneath the hood and realise that they’re not getting any actual oomph there.”

For manufacturers, essentially the most urgent drawback with the clear label is extra that there’s an excessive amount of competitors within the class.

With no common definition or regulation of what constitutes clear magnificence within the US, the boundaries to entry are low. Sometimes, “free from” lists are impressed by the EU’s cosmetics rules, which bar greater than 2,540 chemical compounds to be used in cosmetics.

At Ulta Magnificence as an illustration, that key phrase seek for “clear components” turns up typical clear merchandise like Juice Magnificence’s cream blush, which is formulated with licensed natural purple carrots and champagne grape seed oil. But it surely additionally surfaces Kylie Cosmetics Lip Kits and Maybelline mascara, which exclude the chemical compounds on Ulta Magnificence’s Made With out listing, however use different synthetic components.

Clear Plus

Manufacturers are arising with their very own, expansive definitions to guarantee prospects they’re clear by way of and thru.

Macrene Actives founder Macrene Alexiades printed a manifesto on her skincare model’s web site stating that her merchandise won’t include carcinogenic components, might be perfume free and won’t use plastic packaging. Alexiades, a New York dermatologist with a Ph.D in genetics from Harvard College, backs up every of those claims with scientific journal citations, together with her personal overview article on the estrogenic results of parabens used as preservatives in a wide range of cosmetics and their affiliation with pores and skin, breast and uterine most cancers.

The road relaunched in 2020 with a hero product, the Excessive Efficiency Tinted Moisturizer, made with 45 lively components sourced from medicinal botanicals and marine vegetation.

“I don’t thoughts the phrase clear … so long as individuals undertake the three pillars” outlined in her manifesto, she stated.

Different manufacturers have created a brand new class for themselves they are saying goes above and past merely clear.

TooD Magnificence founder Sharareh Siadat describes her mission assertion as “clear to the third energy.” She stated avoiding components banned by European Union regulators, usually the idea for “free from” lists, needs to be a place to begin, not an finish purpose.

Launched in 2021, the New York-based model options high-pigment cosmetics like biodegradable BioGlitter fabricated with eucalyptus cellulose and colored mascara constituted of 99.3 p.c pure components.

“My hope and dream is discovering like-minded people and galvanizing the massive multi-billion greenback companies to say, ‘Hey, we as human beings deserve a secure physique,’” Siadat stated.

Highr Collective, a London-designed, LA-manufactured direct to client lipstick line made with natural plant butter and oils as an alternative of the petroleum-derived polyethylene that sometimes offers lipsticks their grippiness makes use of comparable verbiage in its tagline “That is clear magnificence, however Highr.”

Launched in 2018 with six cheekily named shades together with the brick purple Chiltern and common nude Chateau bought in recyclable aluminum tubes, Highr Collective is now B-Corp licensed.

“There’s an enormous distinction between having a objective for why you formulate the way in which you formulate versus, ‘Okay, this retailer goes to provide me this badge that claims ‘Clear at Sephora’ if I don’t have this ingredient or I solely have this ingredient of a sure proportion,’” stated founder Molly Hart, an Estée Lauder and MAC alum.

Signal as much as The Business of Beauty newsletter, your must-read supply for the day’s most necessary magnificence and wellness information and evaluation.