Widespread Inaction on Sustainability Eclipses Progress at Fashion’s Biggest Companies

The present decade marks a crucial inflection level for the style trade to remodel in keeping with world ambitions to curb local weather change and set up extra accountable enterprise practices.

Final yr, The Enterprise of Vogue created The BoF Sustainability Index, inspecting public disclosures from 15 of trend’s largest gamers to benchmark the trade’s progress in direction of reaching formidable environmental and social targets by 2030. The outcomes demonstrated a considerable hole between main manufacturers’ public commitments and significant, measurable actions.

This yr, the Index has expanded in scope to look at the efficiency of the trade’s 30 largest publicly traded firms by income throughout three market segments: luxurious, sportswear and excessive road. Our analysis group at BoF Insights assessed every firm on greater than 200 completely different information factors throughout six impression classes: Transparency, Emissions, Water & Chemical compounds, Waste, Supplies and Staff’ Rights.

With simply eight years left to achieve targets, the outcomes are stark: efficiency in 5 out of six impression classes has worsened as incremental progress among the many unique cohort of 15 firms assessed final yr was eclipsed by inaction throughout lots of the new additions.

Whereas technological innovation, coverage cues and standardised reporting frameworks are serving to to immediate motion, restricted accountability throughout the sector, poor-quality information and an absence of funding are holding again actual transformative change.

Download the full report from BoF Insights for in-depth evaluation of sustainability advances thus far, key challenges going through the trade and the panorama for the yr forward.

Transformation, Interrupted

The window for the style trade to remodel its enterprise practices in keeping with world sustainability targets is quickly closing, but change stays incremental. The most important gamers within the unique cohort of 15 firms from final yr have largely emerged as frontrunners, however they’re nonetheless shifting a lot too slowly to attain targets by 2030. In the meantime, a number of firms among the many new additions have but to meaningfully interact publicly with points associated to sustainability in any respect.

General, progress stays uneven, opaque and above all the things, too gradual:

• Sluggish Progress: The common total rating throughout 30 firms was simply 28 out of 100. The very best performer total was Puma with 49 factors out of 100. Burberry was the one new addition to make it into the highest 10 performers with an total rating of 41.
• Dragging Down Efficiency: The addition of 15 new firms to the Index dragged down the typical rating throughout all classes, bar Emissions. Whereas the typical rating of the unique cohort noticed a rise from 31 factors to 36 factors yr on yr, the typical rating for the brand new additions was simply 20 factors.
• Most Improved: Quick Retailing was the quickest mover, progressing by 11 factors to achieve an total rating of 30 within the 2022 Index. Puma and Hermès improved their efficiency by 9 factors every, reaching scores of 49 and 32, respectively.
• No Time for Laggards: Among the trade’s greatest gamers — together with URBN, Skechers, Fila Holdings, Anta and HLA Group — offered little or no public element about plans to deal with their environmental and social impression, all scoring fewer than 10 factors.

The Index Methodology:

The BoF Sustainability Index examines the ten greatest public firms by annual income in 2020 throughout three distinct trend trade verticals: luxurious, excessive road and sportswear. It assesses efficiency throughout six impression classes: emissions, transparency, water & chemical substances, waste, supplies and employees’ rights.

Inside these classes, the businesses are benchmarked in opposition to 16 formidable environmental and social targets established by The Enterprise of Vogue in session with a bunch of revered world consultants. Every of the targets incorporates a sequence of binary metrics (201 in whole) that have been scored “sure” or “no” based mostly on info that was publicly accessible on or previous to December 31, 2021.

12 months-on-year, the methodology has been up to date and condensed; firms’ 2020 scores have been up to date accordingly on this yr’s report.

The businesses assessed in The BoF Sustainability Index 2022 are: Abercrombie & Fitch Co., Adidas, American Eagle Outfitters, Anta Sports activities, Asics, Burberry Group, Capri Holdings, Quick Retailing, Fila Holdings Corp., Hole Inc., H&M Group, Hermès, HLA Group Corp., Inditex, Kering, Levi Strauss & Co., Lululemon Athletica, LVMH, Subsequent PLC, Nike Inc., Prada Group, Puma, PVH Corp., Ralph Lauren Corp., Richemont, Skechers USA, Tapestry, Underneath Armour, City Outfitters Inc. and VF Corp.

Extra info on the methodology is accessible in our FAQs, or purchase the report from BoF Insights to evaluate it in full.

Opens in new window

The BoF Sustainability Index relies on a binary evaluation that examines firms’ public disclosures up till Dec. 31, 2021. It must be seen as a proxy for sustainability efficiency and never an absolute measure. BoF accepts promoting preparations from a variety of companions, a few of which can seem in The Sustainability Index. Such promoting preparations and the Index are dealt with by separate components of the enterprise. LVMH is a part of a bunch of buyers who, collectively, maintain a minority curiosity in The Enterprise of Vogue. All buyers have signed shareholders’ documentation guaranteeing BoF’s full editorial independence.